Its Saturday evening and I’m forced to back up manually every single piece of data from my iMac G5. Why? Because the VRAM is now crumbling (all the Mac icons not only have a cross-hatched box around them, the screen is now blurring everything)* see faults below.
This started to happen before the machine was 2 years old. It’s now 2 years 2 months and its going to be in a skip in a matter of days. Why? Because the repair is £600 – and because I wasn’t prepared to pay the extra £139* for ‘Extended’ Apple Care cover in the first place.
Faults since purchase:
• Fan so noisy that the machine cannot be used for podcasting / recording - known fault
• Power supply failed completely after several months of intermittent shutdowns (Apple replaced under considerable pressure) - known fault
• VRAM failure (renders the machine unusable for anything that requires moving image) - known fault
• * Blurring graphics / text - traced to bug in an obscure ‘Universal Access setting’ remedied only via user forums - known bug
• CD & DVD Burner no longer work
Despite the fact that all the problems this machine has suffered from are well known to Mac – a fact attested to by their ‘limited’ admission of liability in the form of a Repair Extension Programme covering a certain range of machines (not mine of course), Apple have nothing to say about this situation. “You had the choice to take out the Extended Apple Care cover” was their last word on the subject. It appears there are virtually no guidelines as to what length of service should make a computer ‘fit for service’ so Apple and others can continue to manufacture machines that – to all intents and purposes – demand an extended warranty to make them viable propositions as business machines.
As I said in another post, our teenage son’s 5+ year old Packard Bell is still whirring away in his bedroom. Losing our business’s principal computer to a total breakdown is infuriating – but it gets worse. Not only has the VRAM failed almost completely, the CD / DVD burner has progressively given up over the last few months alongside the other problems. So as if to add insult to injury, I am not even able to backup my business data to CD or DVD. As we speak, I’m having to transfer it (painstakingly slowly) across our wireless network to our iBook which itself is not working properly. That means I’m still going to have to back all that data up AS WELL to disk because in all likelihood, I’m going to have to press our PC laptops into service.
A computer that fails twice with known problems before its first two years are up is not, as far as I’m concerned, fit for the purpose. And make no mistake, if taking out expensive extended Apple Care cover is the only way you’re going to be able to depend on this machine still working two years later, then it’s not - as the Apple customer service lady informed me – “a choice”, it’s actually what I would call “a pre-requisite“.
Apple stood its ground and refused to fix this machine. If we did this for you, they said, what about all the other people who had paid for the extra cover?
What they don’t seem to understand is that in turning me from the net promoter I used to be (selling their product for them to cohort upon cohort of students over 10 years lecturing at Universities) to a net detractor, they’ve already lost £900 (the Mac I’m now not going to buy). And that’s before I share my personal – and considered – experience with countless people from this point onwards. So by my reckoning, it’s already lost them financially more than it would have cost them in cash to fix the machine. And that’s before even considering the impact of negative feedback I will be sharing with all the people in future who ask me ‘Mac or PC?’.
I can see that there have been views in to this Blog from the Apple technical forums where I posted my dissatisfaction. People will make up their own minds as to whether or not they’re willing to pay for extended Apple Care or risk their business machine failing with faults that aren’t even worth repairing.
*corrected figure