A friend sent me a link to ‘Zeitgeist – The Movie’ and said I should take a look. I did. It’s worrying stuff.
Why? Because it reveals that far from helping us transcend our historical tendency to control, distort and manipulate the ‘truth’, the internet is accelerating this process and ‘Zeitgeist – The Movie’ is a perfect – and frankly scary – example of how.
In her podcast a few months ago, Nancy Williams quoted someone defining truth as ‘information about which there is no serious dispute’.
It’s not important who it was. What matters to me is that definition has been burrowing around inside my thinking for the last couple of months… worrying me.
Why? Let’s consider that definition carefully. Truth is information about which there is no serious dispute.
That means, first and foremost, things that people agree on.
But it means more. The definition also includes things that people can’t be bothered to dispute. And things that people aren’t able, or allowed, to dispute. This is chillingly familiar in our experience of the 20th century. After all, it’s the first principle of controlling information applied by any government – good or bad.
And this is where we return to Zeitgeist (without even critiquing its content, as Ed Winston does brilliantly here). The first problem for me with this kind of internet documentary is that it is propaganda – a single-viewpoint-communication designed specifically to produce an emotional response.
The second problem is that it is streamed into our homes in a way that is hard to dispute. 2hrs of powerful and seductive visual and sonic experience, a relentless flow of information designed to dissuade the viewer from stopping, considering, researching or challenging. We know this to be true. It’s how television works – and why advertisers pay so much money for TV companies to deliver your uncritical, stupified brain to them for marketing.
Zeitgeist The Movie vs. Ed Winston’s puny little text site for the minority of viewers who are interested in disputing the information. No contest 
All of which, rather worryingly, according to our definition, makes whatever Zeitgeist has to say effectively true.
Funnily enough, at the level of its content, the fact that our capitalist culture is founded on, and fuelled by, greed, corruption and moral bankruptcy comes as no surprise to me – and if this video actually helped people come to that realisation (in the same kind of way that Eckhart Tolle does in his amazing new book ‘A New Earth‘) I’d be encouraged by it – and encouraging about it.
But it doesn’t, because it’s about conspiracy and conspiracy is always couched in disempowering ‘us v. them’ terms, setting us up as ‘the manipulated’ against them, the ‘manipulators’. It’s a victim story we find powerfully familiar and comforting – materially and spiritually. Other people doing stuff to us.
Why do we enjoy conspiracies so much? Perhaps Zeitgeist shows us the answer to this. Maybe its because belief in a wicked ‘them’ allows us to believe in an innocent ‘us’. It’s not our actions that have brought about the meltdown of our global economic systems or the destruction of the global ecosystem. It’s theirs! Theirs and those of their evil conspirators!
“International bankers sought to bring about a condition of despair, so that they might emerge the rulers of us all”.
Forget ‘international bankers’. How much of your own life is shaped by it? Where, exactly, in your pursuit of wealth, your dreams of fame or success are you so different? When are we going to climb out of the ‘win-lose’ trench?
The big scary conspiracy stuff is just a way of focusing the destructive greed and corruption of capitalism away from ourselves into some kind of external ‘other’ that we can make into a scapegoat for all that’s wrong with our world. It’s never been any different, whether we’ve pointed our fingers at heathens, Jews, Communists or, more recently, financial speculators. Our continuing unwillingness to take personal responsibility is probably the biggest barrier to our evolution – and Zeitgeist just an example that unwillingness.
Remember this definition for the internet age: truth is information about which there is no serious dispute – and as the wholesale swallowing of Zeitgeist proves, truth is becoming that which nobody has inclination – or the faculties – any longer to contest.
This is by far the best article,rebuttal, opinion(or what ever you want to label it) on this subject i have come across yet. In fact its the one i have been looking and one of many, that i have taking the time to comment on
I too was sucked into this thought provoking film, Zeitgeist in a negative way and began to worry. Weeks went on, and my thirst for knowledge became over powering. I have read many posts and blogs, viewed dozens of movies and videos from both sides of the argument and i have come to the conclusion that nobody knows 100% what the F@#$ their talking about. I realize that i may not get the answers i am looking for. Having said that, i like what you saying here.
Truth-
‘information about which there is no serious dispute’??????
Thats scary shit!!!
I too am an Eckhart Tolle fan, his book “The Power of Now” has been a very inspiring read and i look forward to reading his new book as you mentioned.
Good Post!
-Justin
Thanks for your comment.
Thank you for your honest and insightful thoughts.
Yes, it would be easier if we had a ‘them’ to blame, but I agree that it is our choices and the broken world to blame for financial problems and more.
I also believe that movies and ‘infotainment’ are a scary replacement for the ability to read well, ask detailed questions, not be afraid to have a discussion about controversial topics and know how to have multiple credible sources to back up your information
There is hope that education and parents can teach future generations to be reflective, compassionate and wise versus just dumping in what to think.
Thanks, I just finished to watch the movie a couple of hours ago and I was looking for different perspectives. You showed me a new one, a valuable one “put the blame on others” a comfortable justification for all our acts and omissions.
Thank you again
“With the experience of others I grow”
I would like to say that them is everybody who is not us! Automatically if you eat the brainwashing that you want tó change you get the right to say they are bad.
So many people are already infected with Zeitgeist.
It was like a gigantic wawe.I got sucked into it to, but now I understand, and I want say that Im great fan of Tolle.Stillness Speaks is just what we need in our lifes.Im from croatia! Every where is the same thing with “Truth”. How to stop it now??
Hi Mr. Sunje. Thanks for commenting. Everybody likes to say they’ve found the ‘truth’. I don’t think you can or should stop people pursuing their ‘new age’ projects… nothing needs to be stopped. If it’s good, it will continue. If it’s bad, it may continue until people realise they’re being led by the nose…
didnt think about that,but your right.but Im still a litllebit confused.I meen…end of monetary system,project venus and non-commertial world…It sounds great! Doesnt It?
And I need this book from Ed Winston to figure out what Is he talking about.but I dont no how its called,I meen the book.Who is that guy anyway?
What guy? Ed Winston? I don’t know any more than you can find out by following the same kinds of links and using Google. Good luck!
hey,
Occasionally the new movie (2011 update) seems a little far fetched – but, actually, the majority of its points seems very sound to me. The way that money is created out of thin air (true, please tell me otherwise), interest charged on it (true)… the fact we in the west are exploiting most of our fellow humans (true)..
please tell me what is wrong with these facts? We need to change the way we use and distributed resources – I think most would agree its not at all right that every 5 seconds a child dies due to hunger (or whatever the stat was)… but no one else has manage to propose an alternative system.
In the 1930′s big business started used freud’s theories to sell us what we wanted, not just what we needed.. and so started mass consumerism
My questions to you all is – Is there world hunger?
Do we spend loads of our taxes on wars of terrorism which so far have never really been proved? Are loads of police and fire officers dying of cancer because the US government gave the OK on the air quality after 9/11 so Wall street could get back to business?
Are we a society obsessed with consumerism? What about building 7 – why does the government try to hide it under the carpet ?
The facts are and we only need to look around us the richer you are the more important you feel – those who like Tolle will understand this will feed into a huge ego ( who you believe you are on the surface).
We are now a a culture of consumerists are we any happier? Peter Joseph is arrogant and full of himself but he is still trying to deliver a important message. War is wrong, taking other peoples resources is wrong. I happily pay taxes so I can live in a clean and safe place but I do not want my tax to be spent on war which I am totally against.
We are never asked if we agree with where are money goes. If it is a choice between someone having a job, medical welfare or a nation going to war- guess what I would choose?